Galway Hooker VS Smithwick’s Pale Ale
Smithwick’s is the most recognized Irish ale around so I was very interested to hear they broadened their range into craft beers. Good pale ale is hard to come by so I am using the tried and tested Galway Hooker Pale Ale as a comparison withSmithwick’s attempt at a craft brew.
"Smithwick's Pale Ale's craft brewed nature make it a true artisan beverage. Brewed in individual batches using the finest ingredients: aromatic Amarillo hops, 100% pale ale malt and the prized Smithwick’s yeast" Smithwicks." SMITHWICK'S®
"At the Hooker Brewery, we hand-craft every batch to ensure that the perfect balance of malt sugars and hop flavours are extracted into the beer."
Galway Hooker Irish Pale Ale
First test: Asthetic
Side by side the bottles appear equally appealing. The dark brown glass lays a good foundational contrast for the gold edging on the logo of both ales, allowing the label to stand out.
.
When poured the drinker is met with a crisp golden colour, slightly amber,Smithwick’s is a light colour whereas the Galway Hooker slightly darker.
· It is a deadlock on appearance.
Second Test: Aroma
The Aroma of the Galway Hooker is good and fresh, slightly sweet and floral, whilst still bitter from the hops.
The Smithwick's is slightly more faint, floral and biter but not as fresh smelling as theGalway Hooker. Disappointing compared to Galway Hooker
· One point to Galway Hooker!
Test 3: Tasting
The Hooker is clean, crisp, bitter but has uplifting freshness to it a real sensation and definitely an easy drinker, perfect session beer.
The Smithwicks is light and malty not nearly as hoppy or fresh as Galway Hooker.
· Resulting in another round for Galway Hooker
Test 4: After taste
Last but not least, the after taste but it is the most important test. No one likes a bad after taste in the their mouth no matter how good the beer is on first sip. A good after taste could be a winning beer for the punters.
The after taste for Galway Hooker is like a creme soda, smooth however not noticeably strong which makes it go down easy.
The Smithwick's is slightly sweet in the after taste but not much bitterness to it. Regardless of the lack of bitterness, it is refreshing.
· Galway Hooker comes out on top again for the after taste. Its mild but well balanced taste is very palatable.
A really great Irish pale. In time I think that Smithwick's will manage to get the balance right. Which is forgivable, after all it’s new on the market. Time to allow change and for a loyal customer base to come forward will eventually convey the success of Smithwick’s Pale Ale. Galway Hooker takes its rightful place as one of the best pale ales available.
Let us know what you think!
Let us know what you think!






